I purchased a GP1971F last September and so far I really do like it. There a few things that I’m struggling with. But, it’s mostly trial and error to figure out the best results for our fishing.
We bottom fish, typically in less than 160’ of water. Bottom reading and target separation were most important to us as well. We went with a 1kw chirp TM185M transducer. It’s a beast and the resolution and clarity is awesome.
But, we were also interested in capturing bottom readings while underway. So, we recently installed an FCV628 with the 525T/LTD20 (Airmar B60) thru Hull transducer which is a 50/200 conventional dual frequency. It does have rezboost and bottom discrimination. The rezboost is nice. But, it’s definitely no substitute for chirp in my opinion. And I found that the bottom discrimination is less than reliable when compared to good old fashioned second echo readings. For example, I was directly over a wreck in 120’ of water and the bottom discrimination insisted on mud or sand. So, my faith has been shaken And I will trust the second echo moving forward.
Edit:
Also note, bottom discrimination will not work once you start going more than about 9-10 knots.
My recommendation for you is the Chirp TM185M- it is pricey. But, i think it’s about the best you can marry to that GP1971F
If that price point scares you, drop down to the 600w Chirp.